The theatrical version of this work is mediocre. Even if it is not compared with other works, only the Gundam of An Yanlianghe is used as a comparison. The animation of “ORIGIN” can reach 8 points per episode, and “Duan Island” can only get 6 points at most. . Of course, I would also like to mention that the great writer’s “NT” has only 5 points.
The script of “Duane Island” has absorbed elements of old Japanese movies, many of which have already been answered. There are not only traces of modern Japanese war films, but also the style of swords and halberds (Japanese martial arts), which is not a big problem. 0079TV itself contains a lot of swords and halberds. The style of the animation has a lot to do with the original. reduction. This also exposed a problem. Gundam fans have been calling for a reset of “Gundam 0079”, and the final result may be this.
The reason why the animation of “ORIGIN” is good is because it surrounds the battle of Loum, and the tone of the pattern is good. Even the battle of Loum is just a replica of the naval battle, which is exciting enough. The childlike and human touch shown in “Duane Island” is of course a good entry into the anti-war proposition, but unfortunately the main line of Gundam already contains the story of war orphans, which cannot be further sublimated. How can “Duane Island” portray Duane and The story of the orphans can only be a subtopic of 0079.
Compared with the 39 episodes of TV animation, to describe the warm story of the big white fortress family, “Duan Island” seems unremarkable, and it has very limited touch to the old Gundam fans.
On the contrary, I am dissatisfied with the marginalized scenes of the white fortress. “Duane Island” does not deeply portray Amuro and other people’s bondage. His strong desire to return is just to complete a certain task. Only the memory of Lin Youde playing Amuro can be regarded as a good highlight. As a movie, the director has tacitly accepted that the audience is very familiar with Gundam’s plot from the very beginning, so he marginalized others.
If you add more Amuro to interact with other people at the beginning, and even portray Sera and Amuro a little bit ambiguous, Hayato’s complex feelings about Amuro’s jealousy and friendship are more obvious, and the cynical Casey Tin is more amusing. If you tease Amuro, the story will feel fuller. Kai and Amuro’s deep relationship should be like Ace and Sabo in “One Piece”.
Not to mention that almost all of the White Fortress fighters later became the background version, and they didn’t actually help much. Even if they didn’t rescue Amuro, it didn’t matter much, and Amuro could drive Gundam to contact the Federation afterwards. The white fortress fighters are only used as funny characters. It is hard to imagine that it didn’t take long for them to spend 3 minutes with Amuro in the universe, slashing twelve big demons.
Another point is that the portrayal of the Southern Cross team is also a failure. The relationship between the players and Duan is too flat. In fact, most of their scenes have been deleted, and only the plot of the later battle is retained, which will not have much impact at all. The captain’s hatred for Duan, the logic of the brainless fans fighting with idols, and the female players’ admiration for the former captain were all settled in Duan/Amuro’s chopping melons and vegetables, leaving no deep impression .
Of course, for old Gundam fans, such a well-made Gundam is still worth watching and cherishing. After all, this is An Yanliang and the last Gundam. It may also be the last time Gu Guche dubbed the young Amuro. Maybe he The role is about to be transferred to Cang Yuesheng.
How to evaluate the film, I do not intend to say more, mainly to talk about some of the highlights and grooves in it.
The first is the most controversial Amuro stepping on people with Gundam.
Although this episode can be said to echo Amuro’s recollection of his mother, in the eyes of his mother, he has become a bad child who can kill wantonly. An Yanlianghe also intentionally portrayed Amuro as a decisive shot against the enemy. warrior.
However, this episode is actually a misunderstanding of his mother by his mother, Amuro is not a real soldier, he is fighting to protect the white fortress family. If there is no war, he even hates fighting. He has always let Lin Youde scare and beat him before being forced to drive a Gundam.
Director Tomino hates using technology to develop weapons because his father developed bombs for the Japanese army when he was a child, causing accidents to kill innocent people. Amuro likes machinery and likes to design Gundam, but he doesn’t like to use it for war.
Compared with the original TV plot, using Gundam to step on people really ruined Amuro’s character design. Amuro can launch an attack decisively after discovering the enemy base, but he will choose to rescue the wounded enemy soldiers afterward. If it is necessary for combat, he can stab the cockpit without hesitation. In the face of a deserter who is not threatening, there are many ways to restrict the opponent’s movement.
Even if it’s because of fighting, when Kalma’s fiancee accuses him of being a murderer, and Harmon seeks revenge on him and kills Lara, he still feels guilty, those things are not actually his fault, this kind of compassion Personality, it is destined that Amuro cannot become a cold and despicable soldier like Char.
In the latest comic “Pulitzer: Amuro Towards the Other Side of the Aurora”, Fraubo was invited to attend Amuro’s memorial service, hoping that she could introduce the war hero to the world. Frau refused the invitation. Amuro is not a war hero because he hates war and doesn’t really like killing people. Chika (the little blonde girl in the animation), in order to let the world know the real Amuro, dropped out of school to write “Amuro Lei Biography”, and did not describe a real Amuro from the perspective of a war hero.
Of course, it should be pointed out here that the “Fathers of Gundam” do not portray Amuro the same way. Amuro, who shows Tomino’s personality the most, is the hero who resisted the spirit of the times in “Char’s Counterattack”. There are many in this era. People call for Char, but someone as brave as Amuro who is willing to understand others is even rarer.
0079’s Amuro character, controlled by screenwriter Hoshiyama Hiroshi, is Amuro who is kind and hates war, and it is the original Amuro.
An Yanliang and Amuro in his writing seem to be more like brave warriors infused with Bushido. Although protecting the idyllic paradise is noble, there is just that slight flaw. Although An Yanlianghe is the character of Amuro, the Amuro portrayed this time is contrary to the original TV work, and the incident of stepping on people cannot be completely used as a reference for evaluating Amuro.
As for Kunio Okawara, he only draws the design of Gundam, regardless of Amuro.
Amuro, written by Gosho Aoyama, is a wolf warrior.
Speaking of the comics “Pulitzer: Amuro Towards the Other Side of the Aurora”, let alone the Chinese version, I haven’t even found the Japanese version.
Your Amuro was just too kind to die. He didn’t need to fly into the fire and go to the stone.
This translation, at first glance, I thought it was an official complaint that Lin Youde had no white eyes in the original work. This Japanese sentence should mean that Lin Youde’s eyes were very unfriendly. Blonde John is the original story, turned into a supporting role. This time Lin Youde assigned the task, and he could even pronounce his name. In the game, Lin Youde didn’t even remember his name. In the North Claw Hiroyuki “Gundam Z” comic, he has become the commander of the Federal Navy warship. But in “Pulitzer: Amuro Towards the Other Side of the Aurora”, he is just a staff member of the Sala factory.
Serasan had an ominous hunch about Amuro’s attack, indicating NT’s sensing ability, but it can also be understood that the heroine is particularly concerned about the hero. In Tomino’s novel, Serasan attacked Amuro’s room at night, and the two became adults that night, and Amuro also emphasized that Serasan’s RT was very small.
Attach the parallel universe’s Serasan
It should be this one
The future family of Bazhou has a close relationship with Marshal 369, so he proposed to ask Marshal 369 for help in the future, but 369 is a political figure, and he may not give any help to the request of the eldest lady who lives in the folk. He protects the future of Bazhou himself. In order to give face to the Bazhou family. On the contrary, Rabir knew that Amuro was missing, and was more likely to order a rescue.
Shreka sexually harassed Sera and was beaten, don’t think he’s the only one who is wretched. In the “Gundam-san” comics, Amuro also had a wretched association with Gundam riding a G-fighter. An Yanliang and Amuro in his writings even steal Lieutenant Ma’s pants to smell them. Tomino’s novel also mentioned that Amuro would use a computer to look at the color map. That’s right, it was already imagined that the protagonist could use a computer to look at the color map. This is flesh and blood, the most real Amuro.
Classic re-enactment, Moonlight Murder.
Jeans/white top/left arm bandage, guess who I am?
It’s Saint Seiya
Rebil planned to attack from Europe, take Odessa, and mobilize the white fortress to join the war. This port seems to be very important.
Xiaolin is also a hero, and it is not a loss to marry him. It’s just emotionally, Flau really loves Amuro, and this feeling is hard to be replaced. Flaubo is An Yanlianghe’s favorite character. Like Duan, she adopted war orphans. Although she did not participate in the war as a soldier, she was equally great. When Amuro throws Zaku into the sea, Duane can abandon his sword like a samurai, become a farmer, and become a man full of motherly love like Flaubo. Therefore, although the story is old-fashioned, the core concept of anti-war is still moving.
Source: Zhihu www.zhihu.com
Author: Su Shenzhou
[Zhihu Daily] The choice of tens of millions of users, to be a big cow of new things in the circle of friends.
click to download
There are 16 more answers to this question, see all.
Further reading:
How do you evaluate the plot design of “Mobile Suit Gundam Cucurus Dogan’s Island”?
This article is reproduced from: http://www.zhihu.com/question/535877635/answer/2533457835?utm_campaign=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_source=rss&utm_content=title
This site is for inclusion only, and the copyright belongs to the original author.